Contract of service or contract for services? | Articles | Knowledge Hub | B P Collins LLP Solicitors
Knowledge Hub | Articles

27 January 2015

Contract of service or contract for services?

In EMS (Independent Accident Management Services) Limited v The Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC), a tribunal provided useful guidance for employers as it sought to clarify the indistinct line between contracts of service and contracts for services and handed victory to a small company over HMRC.

The company, which specialised in recovering accident damaged vehicles on behalf of insurers, had for five years made use of the services of a driver. He was paid an hourly rate and was left to personally cover his Income Tax and National Insurance liabilities. HMRC argued that he was employed under a contract of service but the company insisted that he was an independent contractor.

In allowing the company's appeal, the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) noted that the driver operated through his own business and had expressly stated that he enjoyed the freedom that self-employed status allowed him. Although he provided his services almost exclusively to the company, he mainly used his own equipment, was assiduous in paying his tax and had made his own pension arrangements.

Although there was no 'magic formula' for distinguishing between employment and self-employment, the FTT found that the relationship between company and driver could not be viewed as that of 'master and servant'. Clearly both parties were of the opinion that they were working at arm's length and there was insufficient evidence of control to give rise to an employment relationship.

The penalties for treating, as self-employed, a worker who is later judged to be an employee for tax purposes are potentially very onerous. Contact employment law associate Chris Brazier on 01753 278658 or email employmentlaw@bpcollins.co.uk for advice on structuring contracts to minimise this risk.

Stay in touch

Phone: +44 (0) 1753 889995

Email: enquiries@bpcollins.co.uk

About cookies on our website

Our Site uses cookies to improve your experience of certain areas of the Site and to allow the use of specific functionality, such as social media page sharing. You may delete and block all cookies from this Site, but as a result, parts of the Site may not work as intended.

To find out more about our cookies policy, please visit here.

Click on the button below to accept the use of cookies on this Site (this will prevent the dialogue box from appearing on future visits).