A 200-year-old tree was felled and two men got just over four years each in prison. This may seem like not enough for many people with its history and heritage but when compared to sentences for some offences of assault, including those against emergency workers, where offenders may walk free or serve less time, is it proportionate? B P Collins’ criminal team asks, when outrage drives sentencing, is justice blind?
This week, two men, Daniel Grahan and Adam Carruthers, were each sentenced to four years and 3 months (for which they will serve around 40% of that time in prison) for cutting down the iconic Sycamore Gap tree, a 200-year-old symbol of Britain’s natural and historic heritage. The sentencing, while applauded by some, raises serious concerns about media-driven justice and sentencing disparities, especially when compared to lighter punishments often handed down in serious cases involving violence and drug offences.
The felling of the Sycamore Gap tree sparked national outrage. Within days, the story dominated headlines, social media and political commentary. The public outcry led to a swift investigation and prosecution, faster than many cases involving personal harm or abuse.
While heritage crimes certainly deserve attention, the question must be asked: Did the high-profile nature of this case influence the severity of the sentence?
Many victims and advocates have pointed out that acts of domestic violence, stalking and sexual assault often result in shorter sentences or none at all. In some cases, perpetrators receive suspended sentences even when victims are left with life-altering trauma.
If a heritage tree warrants this sort of sentence, why do violent crimes against women and other significant offences so often result in far less?
This case highlights the urgent need for sentencing reform and consistency across the justice system. When public attention has the potential to influence outcomes, justice becomes uneven. This can add trauma to an already traumatic situation for victims. Protecting cultural heritage is important but so is protecting people.
If the justice system can act swiftly and harshly for destroying an iconic tree, it must surely do the same for crimes that destroy lives.
To speak to B P Collins’ criminal team, please email enquiries@bpcollins.co.uk or call 01753 889995.
